NYC Brokers Fee Bill by Chi Ossé Can Worsen the Rental Market

NYC Brokers Fee Bill by Chi Ossé Can Worsen the Rental Market

The NYC brokers fee bill is a controversial piece of legislation that has sparked intense debate among renters, landlords, and policymakers in New York City. Progressive City Councilman Chi Ossé claims that the bill will help renters by shifting the cost of brokers’ fees from tenants to landlords. However, many argue that this well-intentioned measure will ultimately make the NYC housing market even more unaffordable.

NYC councilman Chi OsséNYC brokers fee bill — Image from NY Post

Understanding the NYC Brokers Fee Bill

The NYC brokers fee bill, reintroduced by Councilman Chi Ossé, mandates that landlords, rather than tenants, pay the brokers’ fees. Ossé argues that this change will alleviate financial burdens on renters. Yet, the reality may be far different. Landlords who cannot absorb the additional costs are likely to pass these expenses on to tenants in the form of higher monthly rents. This outcome was even acknowledged by Ossé’s office when the bill was first introduced in June 2023.

The Potential Impact on Rent Prices

Rent costs in Manhattan, Queens, and Brooklyn are already at record highs. By implementing the NYC brokers fee bill, landlords are expected to increase rents to cover the upfront cost of brokers’ fees. This increase would be distributed over the lease term, making the New York City rental market even more challenging for tenants.

NYC brokers fee bill by Chi Ossé | Housing Cost Increase in NYC — Canva image

Consequences for Rent-Stabilized Apartments

The bill poses significant challenges for landlords of rent-stabilized apartments. These property owners often struggle with maintenance and other expenses. Forcing them to cover brokers’ fees could lead to some units being kept off the market, reducing the availability of affordable housing. This unintended consequence could exacerbate the city’s housing crisis, pricing out more New Yorkers from their homes.

Alternatives for Renters

Currently, renters can avoid brokers’ fees by seeking no-fee apartments listed on platforms like Zillow and StreetEasy. Not all landlords use brokers, and many tenants find affordable housing without incurring additional fees. The NYC brokers fee bill, therefore, seems to introduce an unnecessary layer of complexity to the rental process.

The Way Forward

The City Council will hold a hearing on the Fairness in Apartment Rental Expenses (FARE) Act on June 12. It is crucial for members to consider the broader implications of this legislation. While the NYC brokers fee bill aims to protect renters, it may ultimately harm them by driving up rents and reducing housing availability. Policymakers must carefully weigh the potential consequences before moving forward.

8 Best New York Remodeling Companies for Kitchen & Bath [2024]

If you live in New York and you’re looking to upgrade your kitchen or bathroom stylishly and functionally, we’ve put together a guide on the top 8 New York remodeling companies.

The NYC brokers fee bill, despite its good intentions, threatens to worsen the already tight rental market in New York City. By increasing rent prices and reducing affordable housing options, it could have the opposite effect of what was intended. It is essential for the City Council to reject this bill in favor of more effective measures to address housing affordability.